Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Olson Goes to China

The legal world is abuzz with Ted Olson's testimonial on behalf of gay marriage in Newsweek as Perry v. Schwarzenegger kicks off in federal court. He and David Boies, who faced off in Bush v. Gore in 2000, are joining forces to make the case that Proposition 8 is, in essence, unconstitutional.

It's a stunning argument, and shows why the former Bush administration Solicitor General is among the top barristers in the country. It's safe to say that if Olson wins this case before the Supreme Court, he'll secure for himself a place among the top barristers in American history, alongside Daniel Webster, not just John Roberts.

I have little to add to this story that others cannot with greater sophistication; for now, it may be helpful to bookend Olson's Newsweek turn with this NY Times profile from August 2009, which includes this interesting nugget from Robert Bork:

Conservative colleagues are kinder, but many remain bewildered. Former Judge Robert H. Bork, a close friend who has called same-sex marriage a “judicial sin,” said he could not bear to speak to Mr. Olson about the case.

“I don’t want to get into an argument,” Mr. Bork said. “But I’d like to know why.”


From a critical legal studies perspective, Olson and Co. are likely counting on the votes of Breyer, Sotomayor, Stevens and Ginsburg. It takes one more vote, and that vote would likely come from Anthony Kennedy, who wrote the majority opinion in each of Romer v. Evans, the 1996 case that invalidated a Colorado constitutional amendment on the basis that it violated rational basis scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause and Lawrence v. Texas, the 2003 case that invalidated state laws against same-sex sodomy on the basis of substantive due process (for non-lawyers, essentially a sister doctrine of equal protection).

We can't probe Justice Kennedy's brain, but two takeaway points from Lawrence may show where this is headed:

In her concurrence, then-Justice Sandra Day O'Connor argued that the sodomy law not only violated the Due Process Clause, but violated the Equal Protection Clause under a rational-basis scrutiny -- i.e., that there wasn't a reasonable relationship to a legitimate government interest). (Incidentally, I'd be fascinated in the takes of both retired Justice O'Connor and Justice Souter on this case).

In his dissent, Justice Scalia argued as follows:

The Texas statute undeniably seeks to further the belief of its citizens that certain forms of sexual behavior are “immoral and unacceptable"... the same interest furthered by criminal laws against fornication, bigamy, adultery, adult incest, bestiality, and obscenity.... The Texas statute, [the majority] says, “furthers no legitimate state interest which can justify its intrusion into the personal and private life of the individual."....

This effectively decrees the end of all morals legislation. If, as the Court asserts, the promotion of majoritarian sexual morality is not even a legitimate state interest, none of the above-mentioned laws can survive rational-basis review.


Scalia is prescient in at least this regard -- presumably, under the Lawrence reasoning, Prop 8 and referenda and state laws like it could be rendered unconstitutional without even so much as proclaiming gays and lesbians as a protected class, and it's really just a jurisprudential baby step from Lawrence.

Monday, January 11, 2010

Vancouver: What We ♥d.



Wine: British Columbia wine isn't well known; the volume simply isn't sufficient for massive export. Okanagan Valley wines are a great place to start, but by all means do not cover the field. Poplar Grove's 2005 Syrah was the best I tried.

Design: nood (New Objects of Desire) is a fun Canadian line of well-designed houeshold products. The umbrella was exciting, especially in rainy Vancouver.

Leather: mo851. A Montreal-based company that designs bags and other leather goods. Move over, Jack Spade. Their colors are amazing, and the bags are designed so as to be neither too masculine nor too feminine.

Places: Sun Yat-sen Chinese Garden was well-designed and a delightful space, especially on a rainy day. Particularly peaceful in light of the not-always benign surroundings of Vancouver's Chinatown.

Food: Hapa Izakaya in the West End was a hidden gem recommended by a local. Even better when we found that the patrons were about 70% Asian, 30% hipster. The food was among the best Japanese fusion I've had. The Korean hot stone bowl with rice, egg, miso and pork was perfect in flavor and in presentation, and the tan-taka-tan shochu, flavored with shiso leaf, among the more palatable Japanese spirits I've tried. They also have a "Hello, Kitty" drink that's more dessert than libation. Salt Tasting Room in Gastown was also hip, edgy and of course delicious. Trust your waiter to choose as among charcuterie, cheese and condiments. Don't be afraid to try the beef tongue -- its grainy smoke flavor was the best sampling of the night, by far.

Coffee: For a chain, Blenz was better than most, including Starbucks. The mocha, prepared with dark chocolate, was especially decadent.

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Boulez in Winter

From the NY Times:

It will be a homecoming of sorts for Mr. Boulez, who as Leonard Bernstein’s unlikely successor, directed the New York Philharmonic. He has been proving to New Yorkers ever since what they gave up.

He is the last great exponent of European modernism from the generation that emerged after the war. Born in Montbrison, in the Loire, the charmed and charming son of a wealthy factory engineer, a mathematics student turned musician, he attended the Paris Conservatory, where Olivier Messiaen helped introduce him to serialism. An agent provocateur for serial music before graduating and a master of hardball polemics, he caused even anxious luminaries like the aging Stravinsky to feel the need to earn his approval.


His Repons is lovely; Dialogue de L'Ombre Double for clarinet and electronics is a shorter, perhaps more accessible introduction to Boulez.

The Kennedy Center Players performed Messiaen's Quartet for the End of Time last summer; it was among the best moments of musical delight I've had as an audience member.

With the deaths of Iannis Xenakis in 2001, Luciano Berio in 2003, György Ligeti in 2006 and Karlheinz Stockhausen in 2007, only a handful of lions like Boulez remain -- Steve Reich, George Crumb, Henryk Górecki, and Elliott Carter. Arvo Pärt and John Adams for the minimalists. Krzysztof Penderecki if you're truly serious.

All are significantly underrepresented among the Mozart, Brahms and Beethoven of contemporary performance houses.

Saturday, January 9, 2010

54-40 or Coase?


Economics scholars (as well as students in property law in US law school programs) are familiar with the Coase Theorem.


The Coase Theorem states that in a world of zero transactions costs and clearly defined property rights (i.e., that you can buy property with relative administrative ease and you can be certain that the property is yours after you've bought it), the efficient allocation of resources is independent of the distribution of property rights.


The Coase theorem, as one of the lynchpin ideas of the law-and-economics schools, essentially says that it doesn't matter how the legal authority -- say, a judge -- allocates the ownership of the property, only that the ownership is clearly defined. At such point, the actors, who will know definitively how property right are assigned, will be able to negotiate and bargain for rights.


Driving recently from Washington state to British Canada, I wondered if perhaps nations act under a somewhat similar principle. Specifically, I began to wonder if the 1849 settlement of the Oregon Country (during the single term of James K. Polk, perhaps the most under-appreciated antebellum US president) served as the "legal allocation" allowing American and Canadian actors to settle in earnest what would become Seattle and Vancouver. Seattle's creation dates to 1851; Vancouver's incorporation was in 1866.


To be sure, there are other contemporary historical elements propelling the growth of Pacific Northwest cities -- various gold rushes, beginning with California's 1848 gold rush, as well as the general westward expansionary push. Certainly the inception of transcontinental railroads in the 1870s in both the US and Canada were a factor in the growth of Seattle and Vancouver.


Perhaps Dominion in Canada in 1867 could be identified as a secondary "Coase" moment, which, more than any other point in evolutionary Canadian history, marks the moment that Canada transformed from colony into nation-state.


An interesting question with implications for game theorists, political scientists, legal scholars and historians alike.

Tom Ford's film debut


All in all, a very good first film.

It was beautiful as expected from one of fashion's contemporary icons; the use of color contrast to symbolize life/emotion was definitely well-crafted, as were the visuals generally. (think of the use of red in Wong Kar-wai's In the Mood for Love or the use of green in Hitchcock's Vertigo).

Colin Firth did a very solid job with the role and his acting was subtle in a film that was not otherwise subtle. But it's still a solid addition to thoughtful LGBT-themed cinema, and I hope it will receive at least some Academy Award buzz.

The script dragged in places, but I was less annoyed by that -- you'd expect the college kid to have some trite dialogue -- than by some of the cheap plays for audience emotion; Tom Ford could do with a little nuance in his next film. Perhaps surprisingly, the exploitation was more emotional than sexual. I loved the Carlos scene -- you'd also expect a fashion designer to have one scene with a model that oozes sexuality, and it was otherwise a fun respite from the heaviness -- but I wasn't impressed with the heartstring-pulling, such as using cute doggies (and other tricks) to get cheap emotional responses from the audience. The difficult "anything you can self-pity, I can self-pity better" scene with Colin and Julianne worked because its ugliness forced us, as an audience, to question the emotional complicity we've been developing with Colin's character.

I did like that, early on, he wasn't afraid to embrace the awkwardness of absolute silence - no dialogue, no music. The soundtrack, however, was effective and haunting.

The Hitchcock/Almodovar nod was cute but not too cute (think of Bertolucci's flop, The Dreamers).

Also one of the best period films about Los Angeles I've seen lately.

Monday, January 4, 2010

Interesting Seattle fact


The Space Needle, Seattle's 605-ft tower built for the 1962 World's Fair, and a touchstone of so-called "Googie" architecture, was originally painted orange.

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Welcome.


This blog is intended to be a running salon about books, music, art, economics, law, politics, food, drink, whimsy and wit, as we begin the second decade of the 21st century.

A blog that, for example, examines everything from the Lisbon Treaty to the international trade elements of clove cigarette bans to Booker Prize nominees to the best in classical music, jazz, blues and other the best recipes for hot buttered rum to Tom Ford's filmmaking prowess.

A blog that attempts to surprise and attempts to dazzle.